Top 5 African cities on Facebook

Online Analytics

My most-trusted source for Facebook stats, SocialBakers, states that Top 5 African Cities by Facebook Users are:

Africa's Top 5 Cities on Facebook

Graph 1: Top 5 African Cities on Facebook

The list above was compiled from SocialBakers’ Global Top 120 Cities.

At first glance, I thought this was interesting. However, common sense dictated that something was amiss with the list of cities in Graph 1, thus it need to be validated. The exercise started with ranking of Top 5 African Countries on Facebook, using the same source, SocialBakers. The result deepened my curiosity, as shown in Graph 2:

Top 5 African Countries on Facebook

Graph 2: Top 5 African Countries on Facebook, by Users

Given rapidly growing mobile phone access on the African continent that far outstrips landline access and thus influences Internet access, the Top 5 Countries by Number of Mobile Phones is as follows:

Top 5 African Countries by Mobile Penetration

Graph 3: Top 5 African Countries by Number of Mobile Phones

According to StatWorld’s 2009 report, the ratio of number of mobile phones to landlines in Africa is 44:1. DRC virtually has no landlines with a ratio of 223:1.

The last step was to look at Top 5 African Metropolitan Cities by population size. This was to see if SocialBakers’ Top 5 Cities on Facebook appear at all in the list, and none of them do:

Top 5 African Metropoles

Graph 4: Top 5 African Metropolises by Population Size

The only caution relating to Graph 4 is that the population sizes come from Census years that are far apart in some cases – Lagos (2006), Cairo (2006), Kinshasa (1998), Johannesburg (2007) and Khartoum (1993). The worrisome population sizes would be for Kinshasa and Khartoum, and I am not qualified to venture into any speculation about what could have happened to these two metropolises ever since. Being that as it may, these are the official numbers and I am going to work with them as they are.

My analysis shows that the closest stats are found in Graphs 2 and 3, albeit with a slightly different ranking order. This did not concern me at all given the different metrics that were used. Graph 4 has 3 of the 5 countries found in Graphs 2 and 3. Graph 1 is the odd man out, and this confirmed my common sense that something was indeed amiss.

The analysis above lead me to believe that SocialBakers’ ranking of African cities on Facebook is not accurate. But this has not affected the trust I have in this source as the best for Facebook stats. The only explanation could be that this metric is still in Beta version. I have sent SocialBakers developers an email pointing this out. Unfortunately, I had not received feedback by the time this blog post “went to press”. I subsequently received their response, and the body of the email is here below.

SocialBakers Email Response

SocialBakers Email Response, received 14:26, 14/04/12

I am waiting with anticipation for ultimate publishing of accurate report (hopefully not for too long). This will add another feather in the hat of social media’s power of analytics.

Key insight: Do not use only one source for online stats, where possible. The more reputable the source, the better. At the same time, beware of analysis paralysis. My rule of thumb is minimum 2 and maximum 5 sources, depending on the objective of the analysis. 

Do you use a different rule of thumb when performing online analytics? Share your experience with me by leaving your comment below.

ABOUT THIS BLOG | ABOUT THE BLOGGER | LATEST QUICK DIGI-TIP

RELATED BLOGSITES

  • Nuffdotty – where thoughts on the subject of education, mostly relating to South Africa, are shared
  • Diski4Life – a blog about development of South African soccer post World Cup 2010

5 thoughts on “Top 5 African cities on Facebook

    • Spot on, Comark. If anyone should get it right, its SocialBakers. The post was updated with their response, which is in line with my suspicion. Check it out.

  1. Great article Bra Willy. Thank you very much for going the extra mile with the figures. It certainly helps to have more than one source for figures. I have actually used Social Bakers for my Facebook figures in the past.

  2. You are welcome Bra Willy. That was a Big miss by Social Bakers. Hope they can quickly fix it. I think many people rely on their stats. Yes their break downs are very good.

    Thanks for the note on the webinar. Have you considered putting the event on LinkedIn. I will be more than happy to follow it and also help to get the word out.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s